One Tree Hill news, episodes, discussion, and more!
Brooke Davis or Peyton Sawyer? VOTE!
Filed under: News, Polls Posted on: Jan 19, 2009 Author: ArushiBrooke Davis or Peyton Sawyer? This is the epic question. Personally, I’m Team Brooke. Obviously, she’s funny, cute and really fun to watch too. Peyton is dull, morbid, boring and depressed. But you have your own opinion so VOTE NOW 
AND a really bad friend.
I don’t know…there are several ways to look at this and after everyone blindly voting for Leyton, I really wanted to know if there are people with some amount of sense alive who even like Brooke.
Vote! and please give your reasoning below. Let’s have some FUN with this.
Loading ...-A*
Related One Tree Hill articles...
- Who will Brooke Davis choose?
- Peyton Sawyer: What Doesn’t Kill You Makes You Stronger
- Brucas or Leyton? A poll
- One Tree Hill SPOILER ALERT: Is Peyton Pregnant?
- VOTE: Who Is Your Favorite 1940s Character?
98 Responses to “Brooke Davis or Peyton Sawyer? VOTE!”
Leave a Reply
Watch One Tree Hill
You've found the perfect place to catch up on One Tree Hill news, discussion, and episode info. Take part in community about the latest that's going on in the world of OTH. Welcome to One Tree Hill!
VOTE!
-
Loading ...
If Chad returns for Season 7, it’s definitely that Peyton dies during childbirth; Julian leaves too depresses, and Brooke and Lucas raise Peyton (and Luke’s) baby together and fall in love all over again. That’s what I think
depressed*
definite*
im a brucas fan. i would like to see them back in each other’s company though it is impossible due to the current circumstances. maybe if they’re gonna leave (lucas and peyton) do u think it would be permanent i mean they can leave for the next season and be back for the next (if ever there is) and that will kind of make the viewers more excited and crave more for couple scenes, right?!
For me it has to be brooke, shes grown the most (a lot like nathan) and it just shows what an amazing person shes become. i dont hate peyton i just think they make her character really selfish and morbid. Bad stuff always happens to her and people help her through it and yet when other people are hurting shes more concerened with her own happiness. for example when lucas is with lindesy she makes lidnesy feel so shitty all the time rubbing it in her face that lucas is meant to be with her and only her and when brooke got attacked even though brooke lied if someone you’ve known for your whole life says ‘they fell down the stairs’ how can you believe that when they’re covered in bruises? she just couldnt be bothered to care cause she was so content with the fact that lucas asked her to marry him..
basically brooke is better. selfless, strong and beautiful
and what the f**k is wrong with half the people posting on dis thing shes asking WHO YOU LIKE BROOKE OR PEYTON
not which freaking couple you like..
straight up how dumb are some of y’all?
Brooke of course.
Brooke is obviously better with Lucas than Peyton was.
Brooke is also a better person and more fun, exciting to watch.
BROOKE!!!
I am 100% for Brucas! They should totally end up together.
The answer is so Brooke
lucas needs to get his priorities straight. he’s a bad pimp so being tied down with a family is so much better for him. peyton and lucas are perfect together. brooke is too good for lucas. she needs spontaneity and that guy that petyon used to be with looks good with brooke. both petyon and brooke are awesome and i’ll be sad if peyton dies =(
I love both girls but I love BROOKE more!!!
Breyton FTW!
Brooke is my favorite girl in OTH.
Brulian, Jeyton, Lincas and Naley.
Brooke…all day. I love Peyton, I can’t lie. But Brooke really gives the show some edge. Brucas made the show sexier and fun to watch. Theirs no real spark between Peyton and Lucas. Its just the routine of daily husband and wife. Brucas created a fire
You are so right Kiyana!
Brook, because she’s got integrity. Everyone else is weak and runs away from tough decisions/choices. Pretending to be good, humble etc. We all feel hurt, range, anger, bitchy, downright mean at times – it is human. In the whole show, I think Brook is the one character that is upfront and truthful about herself. Next would be Nathan, but he’s messianic – which is terribly overrated.
Plus, Payton is actually an awful friend. Goes back to integrity. It’s one thing to say means things out of rage – that’s almost excusable because the person has lost track of wrong/right in those moments. It’s completely telling however when a person knows wrong from right (like making out with your best friend’s partner for example) and still chooses wrong. The fact that making the wrong choice wasn’t easy, just goes back weakness and integrity.
As for Lucas and who he should be with – payton. they deserve each other. Brook should have a stronger, better, partner.
I love him with Peyton! With Brooke it was all forced, but with Peyton there seems to be an intelectual emotional connection between them, I identify myself with Peyton since the first time I watched the show, and I don’t think she’s alway so emo, she’s just not that… optimistic. But at the end she loves everyone around her, she’s not a bitch and she really loves Lucas & Brooke. I like Brooke! But she just doesn’t fit with Lucas…
Oh! and she’s not such a bad friend… you know brooke used to hook up with everyone, but Peyton really got in love. She was planning on telling Brooke but as she realized Brooke really liked Lucas, she ended the thing between them.
Peyton is a backstabbing two faced bitch who doesn’t know the difference between right and wrong. She’s so f**king STUPID! And “Alexis” she isn’t in love with all the guys she’s been with if u don’t remember she was Nathans property/whore in season 1, he just used her for sex LOL.
Brooke is the clear winner even for Peyton fans cuz the writers decided to keep the show going on with Brooke for Season 7 rather than with Peyton! I guess we know who the clear winner is from the writers’ decisions.
I’m a die hard Brucas fan always have been and always will be, but Brooke deserves so much better than him! Peyton can have Lucas for all I care.. As long as Brooke is happy i don’t give a f**k about that ugly shkank. I would never want Brooke to end up with someone like Lucas. I think Lucas and Peyton deserve each other due to how they (esp. Peyton) treated those around them/her. Do I think they are epic? NO! Do I think they deserve each other? YES!
They both suck anyway! Once a cheater always a cheater. Peyton is a crappy best friend who doesn’t deserve someone so kind-hearted like Brooke. Seriously Brooke have done so much for Peyton and this is how Peyton thank Brooke?! Gosh i hate Peyton she’s so selfish and self-absorbed.
Lauren, how FUCKING stupid can you acutally get? Keith didn’t want Lucas with Peyton LOL, he never said anything like that.. he didn’t care about who Lucas was with as long as he was happy – that was all that matterd to Keith. He loved him with Brooke so just cut the crap already!
Second of all, Brooke didn’t have sex with Nathan while he was together with Peyton – they were broken up if u don’t remember?! Becides Peyton and Nathan were never a REAL couple they were more friends with benefits or whatever you like to call it, they were not in love.. they just had sex together and Nathan wasn’t a good guy at the time so he slept with other girls too and Peyton knew that!
“Peyton never had sex with Lucas until THEY were together”
They almost had sex in the motell when Lucas was with Brooke, if it wasn’t for the necklace, which Brooke had given him, got caught in Peyton’s hair they would definitly have had sex together! But Lucas stopped it cause he knew what they did was wrong. Peyton on the other hand didn’t care about that at all and she’s suppose to be Brookes best friend.. yeah right!
Besides Peyton kissed him TWICE! So just shut up if u don’t know anything.
“Pay attention people.” Yeah you really should pay more attention retard!
OMG!! Brooke all the freaking way. I would choose her over Peyton anyday!
Peyton is the most ANNYOING character ever, she’s selfish, she’s shallow and she feels way to sorry for her self.
Brooke is deep, she’s real, she’s fun, she cares, and she would sacrifice her own happiness for Peyton anyday. Brooke is an AMAZING friend and one of a kind! She’s so strong and independent and i admire that.. She makes me a stronger person too!
Btw the whole Leyton “romance” aren’t very believable for me. I guess they were destined to be together (according to Mark), but I could never believe they loved each other. The chemistry and the passion was never there. It’s just so lame and pathetic. Peyton is too obsessed with Lucas.
♥TEAM BROOKE! BECAUSE SHE KICKS MAJOR FUCKING ASS♥
Why i am on team Brooke;
1. She is kind-hearted
2. She’s always full of joy and happiness
3. Brucas- She and Lucas are the perfect couple!
4. Strength- She’s so strong and independent which inspires me.
5. She doesn’t let anyone get in the way of achiveing her dreams
6. She is always herself no matter what
7. She’s an AMAZING friend
8. Selfless- She always put others above herself no matter what her challenges in her own life is
9. Fashion- She wears really amazing outfits!!!
10. She is mature enough to admit her own mistakes
11. She trusts and opens her heart to people
12. She’s vulnerable – that’s how Lucas always saw her
13. If you’re sad, Brooke can always cheer you up
14. Potential- She has the potential to do anything
15. She’s one of a kind
Brooke has been my favorite character since season 1, i LOVE her with all my heart, she’s so lovely and so down to earth and she brings me strenght and courage. She is by far the best character in One tree hill.
Brucas was the perfect much!this is the true!Sophia Bush/Brooke is so better than Peyton!I thing Brooke willbe happy in season 7 !I cry when lucas married Peyton..I dont hate P,but i am totally brucas fun.
Brooke is the best character ever, i envy her
BROOKE ALL THE WAY!
Peyton is such a boring character. Lucas is always saving her. She is better in the current episodes but back then she was deppressing and boring. No wonder Lucas dated Brooke mostly. Brooke is so funny and cute. Peyton on the other hand is hidden in some darkness.
BRUCAS<3 FOREVER:)
i like them both so it wouldnt be the same without them
Ok both are great. I love Peyton and Lucas’ relationship..brooke and him was just a high school fling. I love them both but hop off peyton cuz she most def isnt boring
Peyton is so not boringg her whole character changed from the beginning her and nathan in my opinion changed the most….Brooke just changed how she felt about boys and put it towards her friends. Haley stayed the same her kindness just broke through and brought her closer to nathan. Nathan and peyton’s characters are so complex, she went from this bad girl who didnt wanna admit to wanting Lucas to this sweet caring & vulnerable person who expressed her feelings across a huge rivercourt….Nathan changed completely so many times…how can u say peyton is boring??
One more thing Peyton and lucas brought hope true love alwayss….they show you that there is that true love…&& they had everything thrown at them but overall knew that they were meant for eachother…They both broke out of there shells from season one to noww…Give peyton a break she didnt have a mother to look to and lonely was the only thing she kneww…other then with brooke…Naley is a huge inspiration to….its believe she believed in him and he became a better person….he believed in her and she went on tour although they had a rough patch they are as happy as can be with jamie…you guys need to get inspiration…remember what peyton said in the 3rd episode how she wanted to draw something to believe in…that whole show gives you something to believe in….If i was an actress that is a type of show i would wanna do…every episode teaches you something more….this was my first hooked show…and i came in latee to the showw….This show is amazingg so accept the characters and understand there true meaning and why they are all just so amazing with there own twist….
I love all the characters…what really upsets me is that peyton and lucas aren’t coming back next season..their relationship is what makes the show amazing…now it wont be as good.
i love brooke, i hate peyton so much shes like all depressed, she should like go off with jake and then brucas can be together again <3 i just think peyton is dull, and brooke is so alive!! I love when lucas calls brooke pretty girl
haha, anyways team brucas all the way 
Ashley you are full of shit, just STFU. Everyone knows that Brooke and Nathan has grown the most! It’s pretty obvious since they were the same kind of persons in season 1 and they both changes because of Haley and Lucas. So i suggest you watch the show before u start talking next time. Bitch.
changed *
de miojo quentinho (q delicia) q os dois eram na serie gostoso de se ver, viraram um macarão alho e olho(bleee)
os dois não combinam , sabe o q tinha q dá entre os dois acabou na 1 temporada quando os dois trairao a brook
ai já daria uma boa historia de um triangulo amoroso,
eu adoro essa serie + confeço q esse final leyton me decepcionou muito eu espersva um poco+ da serie tipo assim colocar o lucas com outra pessoa perderia todo o sentidas das primeiras temporadas q teve todo um trabalho e agora, analizando esse final vemos q não deu muita graça e concordamos q foi meio forçado esse final não sentimos nenhuma sintonia entre os dois mais, faze o q né? só fico imaginando como seria se inves de peyton brook acabace com o lucas seria muito + divertido os dois prá mim tem um q a + bom a unica coisa q me conforta é q pelo- brook ainda continua na serie.
omg peton is the bomb their nothing else to say its the truth
omg there not returnign imm die theirs nutthing mrore too say they’re the main chaactwe
peyton is not boring u guyz ur haterz i watch all their episodes….Ilove u peyton and lucas broooke nathan hakey sawyer jamie q mouth and allllll julian chase mia sam karen debb mouth girl
J..I think that they should have Peyton give birth to a daughter then die in a car crash or in giving birth. Then have Brooke go back to Lucas and have them rekindle an old flame and see were it goes from there. ur are dumb for saying this f**k offffffff man
J……I think that they should have Peyton give birth to a daughter then die in a car crash or in giving birth. Then have Brooke go back to Lucas and have them rekindle an old flame and see were it goes from there.Whats ur problem fo rsaying this are u insane
I like peyton-lucas. I hope they bring them back at end of season 7. But Lucas with a darker side and marriage on the rocks. I would like to see how Lucas would fare with a darker side on his character.
look .. season 1 -> lucas loves Peyton befor she knows him !
..) i love leyton , jooke and naley !
He said he wants to be with her , he wants everything with her ! He said , he knows her befor he had a real convesation.
Sry but when you would lost your mom and your dad is just 3 weeks in the year at home ,you would lost your second mom and you have a bf who is like a bitch (sometimes) i’m sure that you would be like Peyton ..nooo peyton is better ’cause sometimes she smiled ! remember season 1 ( nathan’s and dan’s party) brooke : peyton ? show how you realy feel .. kiss lucas (that means she knew : peyton loves him ) and she also knew that lucas loves peyton )) but then she dating lucas .. but everyone would know that lucas has just feelings for peyton when you see how he looks to peyton ! Leyton have a real conversation.brooke is just interested in clothes and boys ,party’s and so one ! Peyton thinks about important things and lucas too. I just can say “un unkindness of ravens” by lucas sott ! (the words he wrote down) he wants a pretty girl who thing about the live and not about party and clothes ! I like brooke really ! when i watch her in season 6 she is an adult and she loves julian ! Lucas loves Peyton for the rest of his live and everything is good !
Happy end for brooke,julian,peyton,lucas,sawyer,jamie,haley and nathan (and skills
I’m brooke all the way, but I LOVE peytons artwork and at times peytons life changes dramaticalyand spices the hole thing up. But really brooke makes the episodes amusing and funny so you through in a little nayley drama and you have yourself a pretty great episode. I really think that Jake should totally come back with little jenny and peyton will fall in love with both of them all over again. Wouldn’t that spice things up.
I have been and always will be team Brooke/Brucas. Peyton is not i good friend to brooke at all. How could you possibly be team Peyton?