One Tree Hill Episodes

95 Responses to “Brooke Davis or Peyton Sawyer? VOTE!” (Scroll Down)

1. Charlotte
   January 19th, 2009 at 4:29 pm

   

   It’s obviously Brooke, apart from being more entertaining (fashionable, exciting, unpredictable, creative etc etc) than Peyton, her character has been one of the most to change and grow through time (like Nathan). Peyton is as exciting as a plank of wood (no offence) and I’m kinda tired of her relationship with Lucas already. They should bring Jake back to spice things up. That part of her life (and with crazy stalker guy) were the only times I really liked her character!!!

2. Tanja
   January 20th, 2009 at 12:11 pm

   

   My favorite is absolutely Peyton, but this doesn’t mean I don’t like Brooke. Thus I voted for both… There’s no reason put anyone down.

3. J
   January 20th, 2009 at 3:07 pm

   

   I think that they should have Peyton give birth to a daughter then die in a car crash or in giving birth. Then have Brooke go back to Lucas and have them rekindle an old flame and see were it goes from there.

4. Arushi
   January 21st, 2009 at 7:49 am

   

   @Charlotte- Yeah. Exactly. She’s so dull. I mean, c’MON girl! The oh-my-life-is-so-depressing-I-wanna-kill-myself emoness is getting a bit old. And her and Luke together are so SLEEPAY.
   Brucas 4ever. Brooke is awesome.
   @Tanja- To each her own. And that’s nice of you.
   @J- Omg yeah, right? Or she should like, get married to Jake. Totally!

   xo
   A*

5. brucas!
   January 22nd, 2009 at 12:20 am

   

   definitely brooke n lucas! 1) they have way more chemistry! and 2) how they fall in love with each other

6. Bethany
   January 23rd, 2009 at 1:58 pm

   

   I so vote for a Brucas reunion. They are so much more entertaining together, Lucas smiles so much more with Brooke. Not to mention they are a cuter couple. I agree J and Charlotte. They should either bring Jake back for Peyton and have her have a miscarriage or something, or she should die shortly after the baby is born ans Brooke and Lucas can raise him or her and get married. They are so much cuter together, their on screen chemistry should not be wasted like its being!!!

7. brucas 4 ever
   January 24th, 2009 at 9:14 am

   

   i love brucas they have so much more chemistry and it takes time for them to fall inlove which is way more better than saying i have always loved you (leyton)

   lucas and peyton are just like brother and sister because they are so alike but brooke and lucas have so many differences (oppisites atract ) and it is so much more fun to watch. brooke and lucas are so cute together and you can really feel the love.

   brucas rules

   sorry for talking for so long but thats how i feel

8. Love Brooke and Lucas
   January 25th, 2009 at 11:24 am

   

   I just loved Brooke and Lucas, when will they put those two together again? They had chemistry, I loved watching every scene with them. Peyton and Lucas BORING!!! I liked Peyton and Jake get him back so Brooke can have Lucas again. Please!!!

9. elizabeth-anne
   January 26th, 2009 at 9:11 am

   

   i prefer brooke. she is a huge role model for many people as the thigns she has had to face really shows a true reality, i feel that peyton is also a role model but i can connect more to brooke as a character and that is why i favour her more. she shows real ambition and gets over each hurdel even by herself. she really helps u understand things in ur own life and come on shes goergous and fashionable

10. Amber
    January 26th, 2009 at 11:21 am

    

    Brooke over Peyton anyday.
    Peyton is dull, whiny, selfish, and annoying. Brooke is the total opposite. Brucas over Pucas

11. shann
    January 26th, 2009 at 4:01 pm

    

    i just loveeee peyton.
    brooke can be a real bitch sometimes and peyton shows real love.
    but dont get me wrong i love brooke too. i just love peyton more.

12. sidra
    January 26th, 2009 at 11:28 pm

    

    it’s abt time the creatives stop using their own ideas and actually lis to watch WE want..whichis quiet clear that every1 wants brucas..

    Peyton is just too boring..i mean from beginning of the shwo to the end she’s been the same tortured artist always under some or other stress..

    brooke’s fun man even whn she’s under stress she handles it so well..and Brucas totally rocks lucas and peyton are practically like bro-sis man…even if a minority says this – it means sumthing….they’re like SOOO boring their scenes r sooo boringg to watch…brucas even if they hav one sec kiss its enuff to make sizzle the screen…they’re soo amazing!

    Plus brooke seriously deserves lucas..i mean she CHANGED herself she GREW as a character out of lucas’s luv..she brings smile to his face he was sooo damn happy when he was with brooke..plus when brucas were together luke was still there for peyton as a friend..but since pucas hav been together luke hardly has any scenes with brooke barring a few…when she was beaten..i expected lucas to hav a more of a role in that case…so sad…

    Brooke’s lot mroe funt o watch man..i wud say just kill peyton – make her do the go on stop light task once again…oh after she has the baby ofcourse i got nothing against her baby..infact ok u Pucas fans wud prolly bash us brucas fans for this but here’s a q i ask u guys:

    Wht if brooke was in peyton’s place and peyton in brooke’s?? i mean brucas share SO MUCH CHEMISTRY its such a sad thign that they arent together..pucas has never had this chemistry…
    so in order for brucas to get together if peyton has to die then well then they shdu prolly kill her off im telling u it wud be a pretty gud end to her character..
    & do a 5 year lap and show brucas together with a daughter named peyton..tragic yet both pucas and brucas wud be sort of endgame;)

    oh OR…bring in wentworth miller for brooke – he’s proly the only guy i’d be ok seeing brooke with..no julian..no owen..no chase…if no lucas then only wentworth miller ..lolz

13. J
    January 27th, 2009 at 12:38 am

    

    so it seems most want brooke and luke. thus why i agree because these to use to be married in real life thus why when their acting together people really enjoy watching them.

14. OTHfan
    January 27th, 2009 at 6:36 am

    

    Althugh i prefer Lucas being with Peyton that doesn’t mean i don’t like Brooke . I love her. So i voted both. To everyone who said Peyton is always depressed have you even been watching this season lol. She hasn’t been like that 4 a long time. The time for Brucas is over but if he had chosen Brooke i wouldn’t have minded.

15. Arijana
    January 27th, 2009 at 6:37 am

    

    BROOKE !! <33 Peyton’s soo annoying! I can’t stand watching her sometimes. She’s never grateful of what she gets, Look she got Lucas, and a baby + A new ring and then ” Aww, Lucas I really wanted Keith’s ring, !” I mean, C’mon Bitch, What the hell is wrong with you !!??, And she so steales everybody’s boyfriends.

16. Charlotte
    January 27th, 2009 at 7:11 am

    

    lmao Arijana!!! i sort of agree with most of what everyone says but I don’t want Peyton to die!! Just to get a life. I think she should cheat on Lucas with Jake (mmmmmmm) so Leyton is history but cos Jake and Lucas are friends they don’t hold it against each other and stay friends. Then Nikki can come back knocked up with another of Jake’s babies and the drama can start all over again. But it’ll be cool to see little Jenny (another funny little new character like Jamie) and Rachel. we want rachel back too. Brooke is not a bitch anymore, she hasn’t been for ages. I loved her attitude with her fashion range (no fur) and her magazine models (no anorexia). she gets a bad rep. Peyton kept secrets from lucas, was HORRIBLE to Lindsay (Shann) who was lovely and the whole stealing lucas away from brooke if we’re looking back four years.

    and i think the wentworth miller thing is an AMAZING idea. even though julian is kinda hot too.

17. Candice
    January 27th, 2009 at 4:48 pm

    

    I vote Brooke! Peyton has always been depressed and morbid even since the 1st season. It’s played out. Brooke is so much more fun to watch. You dont really know what to expect from her. Shes someone I’d love to hangout with.

18. sidra
    January 27th, 2009 at 5:33 pm

    

    @charlotte: thanks .. wentworth sophia actually hav this little mini fanbase…i dunno i hav seen julian in pics and one video i dunno he’s ok..not my type..i guess i like cute type (lucas typa) guys more..so i dont want brulian…or browen (owen luks so old for brooke)..even julian i feel luks a bit old for her..chase i havent seen him yet..

    @Arijana: she didnt even KNOW kieth and she wants his ring ! yeah right …the only person who can do justice to kieth’s rign is haley or brooke..both of these loved keith..:)

    @OTHfan: yeah now she finally managed to grab lucas away from lindsey & brooke…so she has to be happy..but her character still doesnt hav any depth..brooke’s character is soo interesting she was at first a b****..then she grew up in a mature gf..then a really helpful best friend..who cant ever cheat her best friend (unlike peyton)..and now she’s a great mother..& still her quotes her scenes r SO MUCH FUN to watch..she rox!

19. sidra
    January 27th, 2009 at 5:38 pm

    

    u know wht i m noticing: sum of peyton fans are voting for both brooke and peyton..but most of brooke fans are only voting for brooke..which basically means that brooke is liked by mostly every1….nice:) she is such a sweetheart after all..

    brooke was first a b****, then a dedicated gf, then a helpful best friend, then a great mother..all of her sides were truly amazing to watch:)

20. Danii
    January 27th, 2009 at 6:36 pm

    

    OMG!! Peyton all the way…lucas was made for peyton from the very beginning. no matter who he was with at anytime it was always her. brooke is awesomee but she has that friend appeal. she was lucas’s first love so yeah they were cute but they didnt last. everyone is saying that peytons boring and she shoul die or her baby should be raised by brucas…..that is sooo weirdd. she went through so much in her life with her moms, stalker, nathan, brother, dad, LA while brooke just had a bitchy mom. so you live without your mom at least she had hers. i feel for peyton and i love her. leyton all they way. their baby is gonna b sooo ahhdorableee!!!

21. Danii
    January 27th, 2009 at 6:39 pm

    

    ohh but i loved when brooke kickked that guyss ass!!

22. mandi
    January 28th, 2009 at 12:55 pm

    

    hands down brooke! she is gorgeous feisty fun sweet caring amazing hilarious and so much more! i think lucas put it best when he said “there are two sides to brooke davis, both of which are…amazing!”

    the most perfect act of love is sacrifice! thats what brooke did for lucas and anyone who loves someone that much deserves to have their hearts desire, deserves to get exactly what they want

23. Tanya
    January 31st, 2009 at 3:38 am

    

    Omgg this one is soo easy! It’s obviously Brooke!!! Everyone knows that already and if you haven’t by now then join team Brooke because team peyton is too dull and depressing! Brooke is tooo cute, funny, fashionable, happy, unpredictable, shall i go on? Yeah she crys from here to there but she pulls herself together! Besides Brooke is a very intresting charachter and Peyton is getting too old.

    I personally think she has too much of a low selfesteem problem, there’s other things in life that are pretty bad and everything that peyton feels sad about is resolvable. But being Peyton she wants everyone to feel bad for her. I also believe she’s very self-centered and Lucas, erm PUCAS are getting tiring and old…. they act like relatives! Not lovers! That freaks me out a bit, so they shouldn’t be together. I used to be a brucas fan but now that julian entered the picture, lucas should stay with someone else other than peyton. She’s horrible.

24. DeeJay
    January 31st, 2009 at 10:54 am

    

    I didnt get a chance to vote, but if i could have i would have totally picked Brooke. Not that i want her with lucas anymore, because he really f**ked her over too many times in the past. but they were adorable together. I prefer her with julian now, since that last eppy, the kiss at the end….made me smile

25. GOD
    February 2nd, 2009 at 1:26 pm

    

    Brooke’s a stupid slut and isn’t good enough for Lucas Peyton is sexy and way better for Lucas and for everyone who thinks otherwise is delusional and doesn’t see that Brooke isn’t into Lucas anymore cause shes too busy hooking up with everyone else

26. Arushi
    February 3rd, 2009 at 8:37 am

    

    GOD- Dude…you have issues. ANyone who calls Brooke a slut has issues. At least she’s not sleeping with her best friend’s boyfriend. Who’s the slut now?

    xoxo
    A*

27. Ritaa
    February 3rd, 2009 at 5:17 pm

    

    brooke and lucas are wayyy better. but i thought peyton and jake were an interesting couple. it brought out the best of her, i think. but i dont think brucas is gonna happen anymore, because of the whole divorce thing between them in real life.

28. Sanders
    February 3rd, 2009 at 8:09 pm

    

    I think Peyton and Brooke are really great actresses, and well I have to pull for Peyton and Lucas but I will respectfuly leave it up to the writter and give all One Tree Hill cast members the highest T.V rating. I have watched every show on tv for 32 years and I never thought a show could take me away from watching Days Of Lives at 1:oopm everyday, but one Tree Hill will pull me away from any movie or show. Not compareing Chad Michael Murry to Brad Pit or anything but watch out Brad her comes Chad he is so talented and Hot I just love the new generation.

29. amanda
    February 4th, 2009 at 4:28 pm

    

    i love them both…. but peyton and lucas are perfect!

30. CC
    February 4th, 2009 at 7:33 pm

    

    Are we all watching the same show? Peyton and Lucas were in love from the begining…if he really loved Brooke he wouldn’t have cheated on her with Peyton…TWO times! He’s SO happy with Peyton…they deserve each other. You want to talk about whiney? Oh Brooks such a whore…but she regrets it but shes still sleeping with Peytons x-fiance Jullian!

31. Johana
    February 5th, 2009 at 3:34 pm

    

    TEAM PEYTON all the way! Lucas and Peyton were meant to be from the pilot (just ask Mark, he’s said it).

    Brooke should have thought of the girl code when she moved in on Lucas season one when she knew that LP had something going on (and don’t deny she didn’t do that. Do you guys forget that she was trying to push her back to Nathan so she could get to Lucas? Even though she was unhappy with him and Nathan treated her like crap and Brooke slept with him.) She was a bad friend first! And when She was with Lucas she was insecure and annoying. I think she needed that relationship to stop being the party girl who sleeps around, but it wasn’t a good relationship overall. They parted on good terms in season 4 and I enjoy their friendship now.

    Peyton is not all sunshine and rainbows, but she’s real and she’s tough. She messed up in season one with Lucas, but she broke it off with him for Brooke (and took Brooke’s wrath) and in the end of season 3/beginning of 4 when she was being honest, she spent a lot of time apologizing and taking Brooke’s crap. Peyton and Lucas make the most sense as a couple. They share a connection and a love that goes beyond words (though he did write a book about how much he loves her…Brooke said so herself).

    Peyton is Lucas’ soul mate and he is hers. End of story.

32. Team Davis
    February 7th, 2009 at 8:58 am

    

    Seriously? Team Brooke all the way. Brucas is the ultimate couple. Brooke is cute, funny, beautiful and amazing. When Brooke and Lucas are together their chemistry is the highest on the scale. Boyfriend and Pretty Girl forever. Even now, when you see Leyton scenes and Brucas scenes, the Brucas ones are so much better.

    Peyton has too much drama. It’s a little over board. Jeyton should be together. That’s who Peyton belongs with.
    Although, I have to say, if Brucas never happens… I could definately jump on team Brulian.

33. Ydavis-scott
    February 7th, 2009 at 12:32 pm

    

    OBVIOUSLY!! BRUCAS FOREVER BROOKE IS SO MUCH BETTER THAT PEYTON ALL THE WAY! BRUCAS ALWAYS AND FOREVER TEAM DAVIS!!! THEY ARE SO MUCH CUTE TOGETHER AND THEY LOVE EACHOTHER BROOKE AND LUCAS FOREVERRR

34. MELISSA
    February 9th, 2009 at 7:53 am

    

    TEAM BRUCAS ALL THE WAY. I KNOW ALOT OF PEOPLE ARE SAYING IT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE LAYTON FROM THE BEGING CAUSE THAT IS WHAT MARK WANTED BUT IT DOSENT MEAN THAT HE IS GONNA STICK TO IT. IF WE BRUCAS FANS KEEP PULLING FOR THEM MAYBE HE WILL CHANGE HIS MIND. BUT IF NOT THEN I GUESS WE WILL JUST LET IT BE. BUT DON’T FORGET IN 90210 BRENDA AND DYLAN WAS THE PERFECT COUPLE THEN THE WRITTERS MADE IT A KELLY AND DYLAN LOVE STORY SO JUST BECAUSE WRITTERS MAKE A DECION AT FIRST DON’T MEAN THEY CAN’T CHANGE THERE MIND. WE ALL KNOW BRUCAS SHOULD BE END GAME BECAUSE THERE LOVE WILL NEVER ALTER AND PEOPLE WHO ARE MEANT TO BE TOGETHER FIND THERE WAY IN THE END. LETS JUST HOPE ITS TRUE.

35. Toni
    February 9th, 2009 at 2:07 pm

    

    I love Brooke but i voted Peyton. Because Brooke deserves better than Lucas.

36. Vanessa
    February 9th, 2009 at 4:09 pm

    

    I love brroke cuz she knows what she wants! Everytime Lucas was happy with someone else here comes peyton “oh lucas i love u” geez she needs to just quit it! She did it to brooke and lindsay, its not cuz “they belong together” its cuz peyton is a whiny girl that needs all the attention! GOOO BRRROOOKKEEE!

37. Ashley
    February 18th, 2009 at 7:14 pm

    

    Team brooke all the way
    First off brooke never broke any girl code in season 1 brooke liked lucas first in the beginning but lucas liked peyton and she continuously denied her feelings for lucas over and over again when she had plenty of times to say something before brooke and luke even got together so he moved on with brooke. Peyton even had a chance to say something again when brooke asked her about it before brooke started developing deep feelings for luke and she said it was cool. So thats not even an arguement cause peyton and luke never officially dated until the end of season four. Peyton can get really annoying somtimes she always wants lucas when he’s with someone else the only times I’ve ever really even enjoyed watching her character is when she was with jake he needs to come back. Brooke is amazing,fun,caring ,independent(where as peyton always needs someone) and just plain gorgeous her and lucas had amazing chemistry on screen I mean you can juss feel it they were definitely a hot couple brooke brought out the fun side in him and luke brought out the more caring and loving side in her it was magic. Peyton and lucas are boring to watch they remind me of very close cousins or something the chemistry juss isn’t there they should be friends and that’s all.
    sorry for writing all this it’s juss how i feel team brooke!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Plus peyton is wayyyy to whiny and depressing it’s getting very old

38. Ashley
    February 18th, 2009 at 7:48 pm

    

    oh and as for the whole brooke and nathan sex tape please peyton and nathan were never in love with eachother where as brooke and lucas were. Peyton and nathan had just broken up not saying that excuses brooke’s behavior but she was drunk and that sometimes blindfolds your real jugdement where as peyton was completely sober BOTH times she went after lucas WHILE they were dating so thats not an argument either

39. larriona
    February 20th, 2009 at 9:41 pm

    

    i like peyton she is down to earth and know what she wants but i steel like brooke but i love leyton

40. artemis
    February 23rd, 2009 at 10:20 am

    

    Obviously Brooke is likable and I don’t want to put her down, but I would always choose Peyton over her. I can’t understand people that say she whines too much, I mean there are people out there that whine all the time and don’t even have any problems. Peyton is amazing for all that she’s gone through, plus if she shut off her emotions she wouldn’t be much of an artist would she? And maybe if you looked closely you could see she’s a pretty great friend. Also the whole Brucas romance wasn’t very believable for me. I guess they must have had chemistry since they were dating in real life, but I could never believe they loved each other.

41. peyton4life
    February 23rd, 2009 at 12:31 pm

    

    DEFINITELY PEYTON. her and Lucas just connect. and anyone who sees elsewhere is CRAZY!

42. mj
    February 26th, 2009 at 6:33 am

    

    always loved brooke – she’s talented and beautiful. peyton is the biggest bore. quite frankly this was my favourite show until they jumped 4 years ahead, i’ve tried to stay loyal but havent watched last few weeks cos its sooooooooooooo boring now. i wouldn’t care if it was cancelled now. it’s lost it.

43. Lauren
    February 26th, 2009 at 12:44 pm

    

    PEYTON!!!
    Ya’ll don’t seem to realize that Peyton and Lucas have been destined for each other since the beginning. Lucas has been in love with Peyton since 8th grade (you’ll remember from season 5 when Hayley reads Peyton Lucas’ predictions over the years.) They are just alike, they’re loners, and dark, and have had hard lives. Creative, artists, and crazy about music. The episode in season 4 when they’re playing the music game is one of my favorite clips.
    Peyton is AMAZING. She’s deep, she’s real, she cares, and she would sacrifice her happiness for Brooke anyday.
    I like Brooke, but she’s selfish, she’s shallow, she’s into material possesions…. which is not Lucas at all.

    PEYTON AND LUCAS FOR EVER!!!!!!!!

44. Lauren
    February 26th, 2009 at 12:49 pm

    

    sidra: Peyton knew Keith… have you even watched the earlier episodes… KEITH WANTED LUCAS WITH PEYTON…. HELLOOOO.

    Arushi: Season 4… the video from 2 years before…. BROOKE slept with NATHAN while PEYTON was with him!!!
    Peyton never had sex with Lucas until THEY were together, and she even went as far as NOT telling him how she even felt until Brooke said they were over.

    Pay attention people.

45. Niamh
    February 26th, 2009 at 1:47 pm

    

    Bring Brucas back Mark!! we love them together! In season 5 when Brooke had Angie, they looked like such a cute family when Brooke was doing her sketches!
    Haley and Nathan are so in need of another member in the family… a little sister for Jamie maybe?
    one tree hill… if season 7 is the end i dnt know what i’ll do! im from ireland so season 6 doesnt air here for another few months! i tune in every tuesday after school to watch the new episodes online! and why are there such big gaps between episodes?

46. tlaleyton
    February 26th, 2009 at 4:38 pm

    

    if you like brucas that much just go on to fanfiction its for naley and leyton lovers too brulian jeyton anyone

47. mackkk
    March 9th, 2009 at 7:31 pm

    

    i am so for team peyton. i love love love her and lucas together. they really complement each other while still having a lot in common. i so love brooke too but i don’t think its time for her to settle down yet. especially not with lucas. she’s just too feisty and fun for that. we like to see what she so unexpectedly does. plus her and lucas are like haley and lucas- way too good as friends. so i personally am all about peyton and lucas. and their baby!

48. tlaleyton
    March 9th, 2009 at 8:23 pm

    

    i love both of them brooke for her bluntness peyton for her sarcasim but i gotta say i love team peyton because of leyton couple

49. Bradley
    March 11th, 2009 at 2:09 pm

    

    You all need to get over the “destined thing” with LP. Maybe they were AT the start, but the Brucas relationship/friendship/chemistry became bigger than Mark and anyone expected, but Mark has an obsession with Peyton so stupidly (Not just because i’m a pro-Brucas fan) but because the whole season 4 Brucas breakup – Leyton makeup was stupid and unrealistic. I don’t hate Peyton, i just love Brooke and maybe she was a little slutty, but she was sixteen years old, she was lost because she didn’t grow up with parents so rules didn’t really get taught to her, Peytons mother may have died but she had her father. Like Brooke said to Lucas “You don’t have to comprimise” I was like, what like he did on season 4 after picking Peyton cause he believed Brooke didn’t love him? Oh yeah!

50. Arushi
    March 12th, 2009 at 12:59 am

    

    Bradley! I love you! You are SO right.
    Jesus frikkin Christ.

    xoxo
    A*

51. Win
    March 14th, 2009 at 6:33 pm

    

    If Chad returns for Season 7, it’s definitely that Peyton dies during childbirth; Julian leaves too depresses, and Brooke and Lucas raise Peyton (and Luke’s) baby together and fall in love all over again. That’s what I think

52. Win
    March 14th, 2009 at 6:34 pm

    

    depressed*

53. Win
    March 14th, 2009 at 6:35 pm

    

    definite*

54. skunked2
    March 21st, 2009 at 9:45 am

    

    im a brucas fan. i would like to see them back in each other’s company though it is impossible due to the current circumstances. maybe if they’re gonna leave (lucas and peyton) do u think it would be permanent i mean they can leave for the next season and be back for the next (if ever there is) and that will kind of make the viewers more excited and crave more for couple scenes, right?!

55. OthRocks!
    April 18th, 2009 at 12:05 pm

    

    For me it has to be brooke, shes grown the most (a lot like nathan) and it just shows what an amazing person shes become. i dont hate peyton i just think they make her character really selfish and morbid. Bad stuff always happens to her and people help her through it and yet when other people are hurting shes more concerened with her own happiness. for example when lucas is with lindesy she makes lidnesy feel so shitty all the time rubbing it in her face that lucas is meant to be with her and only her and when brooke got attacked even though brooke lied if someone you’ve known for your whole life says ‘they fell down the stairs’ how can you believe that when they’re covered in bruises? she just couldnt be bothered to care cause she was so content with the fact that lucas asked her to marry him..

    basically brooke is better. selfless, strong and beautiful

56. OthRocks!
    April 18th, 2009 at 12:11 pm

    

    and what the f**k is wrong with half the people posting on dis thing shes asking WHO YOU LIKE BROOKE OR PEYTON
    not which freaking couple you like..
    straight up how dumb are some of y’all?

57. dora
    April 28th, 2009 at 6:03 pm

    

    Brooke of course.

58. kaycee
    April 28th, 2009 at 6:04 pm

    

    Brooke is obviously better with Lucas than Peyton was.
    Brooke is also a better person and more fun, exciting to watch.
    BROOKE!!!

59. kelsi
    April 28th, 2009 at 6:05 pm

    

    I am 100% for Brucas! They should totally end up together.

60. glenna
    April 28th, 2009 at 6:06 pm

    

    The answer is so Brooke

61. jo-jo
    May 11th, 2009 at 10:36 pm

    

    lucas needs to get his priorities straight. he’s a bad pimp so being tied down with a family is so much better for him. peyton and lucas are perfect together. brooke is too good for lucas. she needs spontaneity and that guy that petyon used to be with looks good with brooke. both petyon and brooke are awesome and i’ll be sad if peyton dies =(

62. leona
    May 17th, 2009 at 3:39 pm

    

    I love both girls but I love BROOKE more!!!
    Breyton FTW!

63. Addekted
    May 17th, 2009 at 3:42 pm

    

    Brooke is my favorite girl in OTH.
    Brulian, Jeyton, Lincas and Naley.

64. Kiyana
    May 18th, 2009 at 6:00 pm

    

    Brooke…all day. I love Peyton, I can’t lie. But Brooke really gives the show some edge. Brucas made the show sexier and fun to watch. Theirs no real spark between Peyton and Lucas. Its just the routine of daily husband and wife. Brucas created a fire

65. daisy
    May 18th, 2009 at 6:45 pm

    

    You are so right Kiyana!

66. Mick
    June 3rd, 2009 at 4:15 am

    

    Brook, because she’s got integrity. Everyone else is weak and runs away from tough decisions/choices. Pretending to be good, humble etc. We all feel hurt, range, anger, bitchy, downright mean at times – it is human. In the whole show, I think Brook is the one character that is upfront and truthful about herself. Next would be Nathan, but he’s messianic – which is terribly overrated.

67. Mick
    June 3rd, 2009 at 4:21 am

    

    Plus, Payton is actually an awful friend. Goes back to integrity. It’s one thing to say means things out of rage – that’s almost excusable because the person has lost track of wrong/right in those moments. It’s completely telling however when a person knows wrong from right (like making out with your best friend’s partner for example) and still chooses wrong. The fact that making the wrong choice wasn’t easy, just goes back weakness and integrity.

    As for Lucas and who he should be with – payton. they deserve each other. Brook should have a stronger, better, partner.

68. Alexis
    June 7th, 2009 at 5:23 pm

    

    I love him with Peyton! With Brooke it was all forced, but with Peyton there seems to be an intelectual emotional connection between them, I identify myself with Peyton since the first time I watched the show, and I don’t think she’s alway so emo, she’s just not that… optimistic. But at the end she loves everyone around her, she’s not a bitch and she really loves Lucas & Brooke. I like Brooke! But she just doesn’t fit with Lucas…

69. Alexis
    June 7th, 2009 at 5:31 pm

    

    Oh! and she’s not such a bad friend… you know brooke used to hook up with everyone, but Peyton really got in love. She was planning on telling Brooke but as she realized Brooke really liked Lucas, she ended the thing between them.

70. Leyla
    June 12th, 2009 at 8:21 am

    

    Peyton is a backstabbing two faced bitch who doesn’t know the difference between right and wrong. She’s so f**king STUPID! And “Alexis” she isn’t in love with all the guys she’s been with if u don’t remember she was Nathans property/whore in season 1, he just used her for sex LOL.

71. Win
    June 12th, 2009 at 8:26 am

    

    Brooke is the clear winner even for Peyton fans cuz the writers decided to keep the show going on with Brooke for Season 7 rather than with Peyton! I guess we know who the clear winner is from the writers’ decisions.

72. Hate PEYTON!!
    June 12th, 2009 at 8:29 am

    

    I’m a die hard Brucas fan always have been and always will be, but Brooke deserves so much better than him! Peyton can have Lucas for all I care.. As long as Brooke is happy i don’t give a f**k about that ugly shkank. I would never want Brooke to end up with someone like Lucas. I think Lucas and Peyton deserve each other due to how they (esp. Peyton) treated those around them/her. Do I think they are epic? NO! Do I think they deserve each other? YES!

    They both suck anyway! Once a cheater always a cheater. Peyton is a crappy best friend who doesn’t deserve someone so kind-hearted like Brooke. Seriously Brooke have done so much for Peyton and this is how Peyton thank Brooke?! Gosh i hate Peyton she’s so selfish and self-absorbed.

73. ---
    June 12th, 2009 at 8:54 am

    

    Lauren, how FUCKING stupid can you acutally get? Keith didn’t want Lucas with Peyton LOL, he never said anything like that.. he didn’t care about who Lucas was with as long as he was happy – that was all that matterd to Keith. He loved him with Brooke so just cut the crap already!

    Second of all, Brooke didn’t have sex with Nathan while he was together with Peyton – they were broken up if u don’t remember?! Becides Peyton and Nathan were never a REAL couple they were more friends with benefits or whatever you like to call it, they were not in love.. they just had sex together and Nathan wasn’t a good guy at the time so he slept with other girls too and Peyton knew that!

    “Peyton never had sex with Lucas until THEY were together”
    They almost had sex in the motell when Lucas was with Brooke, if it wasn’t for the necklace, which Brooke had given him, got caught in Peyton’s hair they would definitly have had sex together! But Lucas stopped it cause he knew what they did was wrong. Peyton on the other hand didn’t care about that at all and she’s suppose to be Brookes best friend.. yeah right!

    Besides Peyton kissed him TWICE! So just shut up if u don’t know anything.

    “Pay attention people.” Yeah you really should pay more attention retard!

74. Brooke and Brucas 4-ever
    June 12th, 2009 at 9:18 am

    

    OMG!! Brooke all the freaking way. I would choose her over Peyton anyday!

    Peyton is the most ANNYOING character ever, she’s selfish, she’s shallow and she feels way to sorry for her self.

    Brooke is deep, she’s real, she’s fun, she cares, and she would sacrifice her own happiness for Peyton anyday. Brooke is an AMAZING friend and one of a kind! She’s so strong and independent and i admire that.. She makes me a stronger person too!

    Btw the whole Leyton “romance” aren’t very believable for me. I guess they were destined to be together (according to Mark), but I could never believe they loved each other. The chemistry and the passion was never there. It’s just so lame and pathetic. Peyton is too obsessed with Lucas.

75. whooot
    June 12th, 2009 at 9:21 am

    

    ♥TEAM BROOKE! BECAUSE SHE KICKS MAJOR FUCKING ASS♥

76. Steffy
    June 12th, 2009 at 9:26 am

    

    Why i am on team Brooke;

    1. She is kind-hearted
    2. She’s always full of joy and happiness
    3. Brucas- She and Lucas are the perfect couple!
    4. Strength- She’s so strong and independent which inspires me.
    5. She doesn’t let anyone get in the way of achiveing her dreams
    6. She is always herself no matter what
    7. She’s an AMAZING friend
    8. Selfless- She always put others above herself no matter what her challenges in her own life is
    9. Fashion- She wears really amazing outfits!!!
    10. She is mature enough to admit her own mistakes
    11. She trusts and opens her heart to people
    12. She’s vulnerable – that’s how Lucas always saw her
    13. If you’re sad, Brooke can always cheer you up
    14. Potential- She has the potential to do anything
    15. She’s one of a kind

77. Katta
    June 12th, 2009 at 9:43 am

    

    Brooke has been my favorite character since season 1, i LOVE her with all my heart, she’s so lovely and so down to earth and she brings me strenght and courage. She is by far the best character in One tree hill.

78. Vanessa Abrams fun/brucas fun/Kelly fun
    June 13th, 2009 at 5:33 am

    

    Brucas was the perfect much!this is the true!Sophia Bush/Brooke is so better than Peyton!I thing Brooke willbe happy in season 7 !I cry when lucas married Peyton..I dont hate P,but i am totally brucas fun.

79. Emma
    June 14th, 2009 at 8:25 am

    

    Brooke is the best character ever, i envy her

80. Sandra
    June 18th, 2009 at 6:54 pm

    

    BROOKE ALL THE WAY!
    Peyton is such a boring character. Lucas is always saving her. She is better in the current episodes but back then she was deppressing and boring. No wonder Lucas dated Brooke mostly. Brooke is so funny and cute. Peyton on the other hand is hidden in some darkness.
    BRUCAS<3 FOREVER:)

81. blah
    July 14th, 2009 at 3:42 pm

    

    i like them both so it wouldnt be the same without them

82. Peyton and Brooke
    July 15th, 2009 at 1:21 pm

    

    Ok both are great. I love Peyton and Lucas’ relationship..brooke and him was just a high school fling. I love them both but hop off peyton cuz she most def isnt boring

83. Ashley
    July 15th, 2009 at 4:28 pm

    

    Peyton is so not boringg her whole character changed from the beginning her and nathan in my opinion changed the most….Brooke just changed how she felt about boys and put it towards her friends. Haley stayed the same her kindness just broke through and brought her closer to nathan. Nathan and peyton’s characters are so complex, she went from this bad girl who didnt wanna admit to wanting Lucas to this sweet caring & vulnerable person who expressed her feelings across a huge rivercourt….Nathan changed completely so many times…how can u say peyton is boring??

84. Ashley
    July 15th, 2009 at 4:34 pm

    

    One more thing Peyton and lucas brought hope true love alwayss….they show you that there is that true love…&& they had everything thrown at them but overall knew that they were meant for eachother…They both broke out of there shells from season one to noww…Give peyton a break she didnt have a mother to look to and lonely was the only thing she kneww…other then with brooke…Naley is a huge inspiration to….its believe she believed in him and he became a better person….he believed in her and she went on tour although they had a rough patch they are as happy as can be with jamie…you guys need to get inspiration…remember what peyton said in the 3rd episode how she wanted to draw something to believe in…that whole show gives you something to believe in….If i was an actress that is a type of show i would wanna do…every episode teaches you something more….this was my first hooked show…and i came in latee to the showw….This show is amazingg so accept the characters and understand there true meaning and why they are all just so amazing with there own twist….

85. AJ
    July 15th, 2009 at 5:45 pm

    

    I love all the characters…what really upsets me is that peyton and lucas aren’t coming back next season..their relationship is what makes the show amazing…now it wont be as good.

86. maggie
    July 27th, 2009 at 8:31 pm

    

    i love brooke, i hate peyton so much shes like all depressed, she should like go off with jake and then brucas can be together again <3 i just think peyton is dull, and brooke is so alive!! I love when lucas calls brooke pretty girl haha, anyways team brucas all the way

87. Miche
    August 6th, 2009 at 9:20 am

    

    Ashley you are full of shit, just STFU. Everyone knows that Brooke and Nathan has grown the most! It’s pretty obvious since they were the same kind of persons in season 1 and they both changes because of Haley and Lucas. So i suggest you watch the show before u start talking next time. Bitch.

88. Miche
    August 6th, 2009 at 9:20 am

    

    changed *

89. nayara
    September 6th, 2009 at 4:00 pm

    

    de miojo quentinho (q delicia) q os dois eram na serie gostoso de se ver, viraram um macarão alho e olho(bleee)
    os dois não combinam , sabe o q tinha q dá entre os dois acabou na 1 temporada quando os dois trairao a brook
    ai já daria uma boa historia de um triangulo amoroso,
    eu adoro essa serie + confeço q esse final leyton me decepcionou muito eu espersva um poco+ da serie tipo assim colocar o lucas com outra pessoa perderia todo o sentidas das primeiras temporadas q teve todo um trabalho e agora, analizando esse final vemos q não deu muita graça e concordamos q foi meio forçado esse final não sentimos nenhuma sintonia entre os dois mais, faze o q né? só fico imaginando como seria se inves de peyton brook acabace com o lucas seria muito + divertido os dois prá mim tem um q a + bom a unica coisa q me conforta é q pelo- brook ainda continua na serie.

90. Ilovepeytonandlucastheyarethebestcoupleever
    December 19th, 2009 at 11:37 am

    

    omg peton is the bomb their nothing else to say its the truth

91. Ilovepeytonandlucastheyarethebestcoupleever
    December 19th, 2009 at 11:38 am

    

    omg there not returnign imm die theirs nutthing mrore too say they’re the main chaactwe

92. Ilovepeytonandlucastheyarethebestcoupleever
    December 19th, 2009 at 11:41 am

    

    peyton is not boring u guyz ur haterz i watch all their episodes….Ilove u peyton and lucas broooke nathan hakey sawyer jamie q mouth and allllll julian chase mia sam karen debb mouth girl

93. Ilovepeytonandlucastheyarethebestcoupleever
    December 19th, 2009 at 11:41 am

    

    J..I think that they should have Peyton give birth to a daughter then die in a car crash or in giving birth. Then have Brooke go back to Lucas and have them rekindle an old flame and see were it goes from there. ur are dumb for saying this f**k offffffff man

94. Ilovepeytonandlucastheyarethebestcoupleever
    December 19th, 2009 at 11:42 am

    

    J……I think that they should have Peyton give birth to a daughter then die in a car crash or in giving birth. Then have Brooke go back to Lucas and have them rekindle an old flame and see were it goes from there.Whats ur problem fo rsaying this are u insane

95. lifeafterdeath
    December 20th, 2009 at 2:54 pm

    

    I like peyton-lucas. I hope they bring them back at end of season 7. But Lucas with a darker side and marriage on the rocks. I would like to see how Lucas would fare with a darker side on his character.